Company Officer Forge, home

Articles / Buddy to Boss

Buddy to Boss: A Field Guide to Leading Former Peers as a New Fire Officer

Stage by stage, from the days before your first shift to day 90: what to say, what to watch for, and the mistakes to skip.

Buddy to Boss · 15 min read

Short on time? Read the short version: Promoted Over Your Friends. Want to work through your own crew on paper? Print the free Buddy to Boss Worksheet and fill it in as you read.

You studied for months. You passed. Somebody pinned the bugles on your collar, and people clapped.

Then you walked into the kitchen for your first shift in the seat, and the same people who were razzing you about your cooking last week went quiet when you sat down.

Nobody's being cruel. They just don't know who you're going to be yet. Truth is, neither do you.

This guide goes stage by stage, from the days before your first shift to the end of your first 90. Take it a section at a time.

Why this is harder than it looks

Leading strangers is hard. Leading people who know your history is harder. They've seen you at your worst. They know which rules you used to bend. Some of them wanted your job.

Linda Hill of Harvard Business School followed 19 new managers through their first year for her book Becoming a Manager. Her conclusion was that stepping up is a real psychological shift, a change in identity and not just a change in duties, and that people learn it mostly from experience. Translation: you will get some of this wrong, and that's normal. What matters is how fast you learn.

None of that means you're the wrong person for the seat. It means the first few months need a plan, not hope. That's what the rest of this guide is.

Stage 1: Before your first shift

Make the mental break

Start by letting go of the old job in your head before you take the new one. Not every habit that made you a good firefighter carries over. Maybe you were first on the nozzle, or the one with the joke during the gripe session about the new policy.

Now your job is the whole crew, the radio, and the big picture. Decide now which old habits stay home.

Map your crew

Before you walk in, sit down with Part 1 of the worksheet and write down every name on your shift. For each person, answer honestly:

  • How close are we? Who do you hang out with off duty? Whose kids' birthday parties do you go to?
  • Did they test for this spot? Who wanted the job you got?
  • Who's likely to test you? Not who you don't like. Who's most likely to push to see where the line is?
  • Who carries this shift quietly? Every crew has someone who does the work without being asked. Don't overlook them because they don't need managing.

This isn't a list of good and bad people. It's a map of where friction is likely to show up.

Talk to your BC before day one

Your relationship with your battalion chief is one of the most important ones you have in this seat, and it's easier to build before there's a problem.

Call before your first shift, introduce yourself, and ask when you can sit down face-to-face in your first two weeks. When you do, ask three things: what they expect from their company officers, what they want to hear about right away versus at end of shift, and what they already know about your crew that you should know.

Hill found that new managers often avoid asking their bosses for help, and that when they finally do, their bosses are more tolerant of questions and mistakes than they expected. Ask early, while it's still a normal question and not a crisis.

Write your one or two standards

Pick one or two standards you will hold every single shift, starting with yourself: the top one or two of the three to five expectations you lay out on day one. Write them down. (More on how to pick them in Stage 4.)

Decide what you won't change yet

Unless it's a safety or policy problem, it can wait. Write down two or three things you'll leave alone until you've watched how the shift actually runs.

Common mistakes before day one:

  • Showing up with a list of changes. The crew reads it as "everything you've been doing is wrong."
  • Skipping the BC conversation because you don't want to look like you need help.
  • Assuming the friendships will just sort themselves out.

Stage 2: Your first line-up

Your first line-up is the clearest chance you'll get to mark the change out loud. If you let it slide by, the crew will keep treating you like the old version of you, and you'll spend months fighting that.

Keep it to about two minutes. Here's one way it can sound. Make it yours.

"Alright. Yeah, this is different. It's different for me too, so let's just say it out loud.

Here's what doesn't change. I'm still going to cook, still going to check the rig with you, and I'm still going to have your back, up the chain and on the street.

Here's what does. I make the call now. When I get it wrong, I'll own it.

I've got a few expectations for this shift, and I'll go over all of them today. Two I'm going to hold every shift, starting with me: rig and SCBA checks are done before coffee, and if you need a trade or you're running late, I hear it from you before the shift, not after.

And one ask. If I'm getting something wrong, tell me. In the office, not in front of the crew. Okay. Let's go check the rig."

Then go check the rig with them.

Common line-up mistakes:

  • Too long. A ten-minute speech sounds like you're trying to convince yourself.
  • "Nothing's going to change." It already did. They know it. Saying otherwise costs you credibility on day one.
  • Apologizing for the promotion. You earned it. Humble is good. Sorry is not.
  • Announcing changes. Save them. You haven't earned the right yet, and you don't know enough.

Stage 3: The one-on-ones

Two conversations come first, in your first couple of shifts, and they need extra thought: your closest friends on the crew and anyone who also tested. After that, plan a short sit-down with every person on your crew in your first 30 days. Tell them at line-up that everybody gets one and why, so nobody thinks they're being called to the principal's office.

Your closest friends on the crew

Do it in private, early, before anything has gone wrong:

"You're one of my best friends on this job, and that doesn't change. But I can't give you a pass I wouldn't give anybody else, and the crew is going to be watching to see if I do. So if I come down on you for something, it's not personal. And if you think I'm being unfair, tell me in private. I'll listen."

Then ask them what they need from you. Listen for worry. Your friend might be afraid of losing the friendship more than anything else. Tell them the friendship isn't going anywhere. The free passes are.

The person who also tested

This is the conversation new officers dread, so they put it off. Don't. The longer you wait, the more the silence fills in with stories.

Your goal is to bring them into what you're building instead of leaving them on the outside. Don't apologize for getting the job. Don't pretend it didn't happen either.

"I know you wanted this spot, and honestly, you'd have been good at it. I'm not going to pretend that's not awkward. I want you to be a big part of how this crew runs. What do you want to work on this year? And if you're testing again, I'd like to help you get ready."

Then follow through. Give them real responsibility: a drill to run, a piece of equipment to own, a probie to bring along. Ask their opinion in front of the crew when they know more than you do.

If they're still working against you after you've done all that, that's a different problem. Handle it the way Stage 6 describes, and keep your BC informed with facts.

Everyone else

Everyone else gets a sit-down in your first 30 days. Keep them simple. What do you want to get better at? Are you thinking about testing? What's one thing you need from me? Write the answers down. Part 4 of the worksheet has space to plan each one.

Stage 4: Three to five expectations, one or two standards

On day one, lay out three to five expectations for how this crew works on your shift. Out of those, pick the one or two you'll hold hardest, every shift, starting with yourself. Those are your standards. Whatever's on the list applies to everybody the same way, you included.

How to pick your standards

A good standard has three things going for it:

  • You can see it. "Show more pride" is a feeling. "Rig and SCBA checks done and written up before coffee" is something you can check.
  • You'll enforce it on a bad day. If you won't correct it at 0700 after a rough night, don't say it.
  • It applies to you first. The crew will check. They should.

Leave policy to policy. Discipline, leave, and safety rules already live in your department's policies, SOPs, and SOGs. Your standards are about how this crew works on your shift.

How to hold it

The first time a standard gets tested sets the price for every time after. If your best friend skips the rig check and you let it go, you've just told the crew the standard is for other people.

There's a trap on the other side too. Some new officers come down harder on their friends to prove they aren't playing favorites. That's still unfair. It's just unfair in the other direction, and your friends will notice.

The answer is boring and it works: the same standard, the same response, every time, for everybody. Hill's line is worth remembering: "Compliance does not equal commitment." You can force compliance for a while. Commitment comes when the crew believes you're fair.

Stage 5: Your first correction, worked through

Here's a made-up example to show how one of these can go. Jay has been on the job about as long as you have. You rode backward together for years. Two shifts in a row, his SCBA check didn't get done, and the second time he wrote it up as done anyway.

Prep before you say a word

Part 5 of the worksheet walks through this. Answer five questions first:

  1. Facts. What happened, exactly, and how do you know? (Two shifts. Check logged on the second shift, but the cylinder was low and the low-air alarm wasn't tested.)
  2. Policy. What does your department's policy, SOP, or SOG say about equipment checks and documentation?
  3. Behavior. What's the behavior, in one sentence, with no labels? ("The check didn't get done, and it got written up as done.")
  4. Expectation. What needs to happen from here on?
  5. Documentation. What will you write down, and does this need to go anywhere formal under your department's process?

Pick the time and place

In the office, before the shift gets going. Not on the apparatus floor and not at the kitchen table.

The conversation

The National Fire Academy's Leadership in Supervision course covers difficult conversations and something it calls advocacy-inquiry dialogue. In plain terms: say what you saw and why it matters, then ask for their side and actually listen. Here's how that might sound.

You: "Got a minute? Shut the door. Jay, your SCBA check didn't get done last shift or the shift before. Last shift it got written up as done, and the cylinder was low and the alarm wasn't tested."

Jay: "Come on, it's me. You know I've got it. We got slammed with calls."

You: "I do know you, and that's why I'm bringing it to you straight. That pack is somebody's air. If it's written up as checked, the next person trusts it. What happened?"

Jay: "Honestly, I figured I'd get to it and I didn't."

You: "Fair enough. Here's what I need from here on: checks get done before coffee, and nothing gets written up that didn't happen. If we get slammed, tell me and we'll figure it out. Can you do that?"

Jay: "Yeah."

You: "Good. I'm making a note of this conversation, same as I would for anybody. Now let's go eat."

Why it works

It's private and sticks to facts. It names the behavior, not the person ("lazy" never comes up). It explains why it matters in terms Jay already cares about, asks for his side, and ends with a clear expectation and a normal next step.

When he says "Come on, it's me," you don't argue about the friendship. You agree with it and use it. That's how you go straight at the problem without going after the person.

After

Write it down the same day: date, what was said, what was agreed. Follow your department's process for anything formal. Don't discuss it with anybody else on the crew. Next shift, treat Jay like everyone else. A correction that hangs over someone for weeks stops being a correction.

Stage 6: Pushback and testing behavior

Expect somebody to test where the line is early on. Here are some common tests and how to handle them.

  • "That's not how we've always done it." Ask why it's done that way. Sometimes there's a good reason and you learn something. If there isn't, say: "I hear you. Here's how we're doing it on this shift, and here's why."
  • The public challenge. Someone argues with a call in front of the crew. On a scene, finish the work first. Around the station, don't win the argument in public. Say: "Let's talk about it in the office after this." Then actually have that talk.
  • Slow-walking. The task gets done, eventually, badly. Name it privately with facts: what was asked, when, and what happened.
  • The sarcastic "Yes, Lieutenant." Let the first one go. If it keeps up, have a private word: "Sounds like something's bugging you. Let's hear it."
  • The end-run. Someone goes around you to the BC or to your old officer. Don't take it personally in public. Talk to them, and give your BC the facts before they hear a version from someone else.

Some things are above your pay grade. Harassment, serious safety violations, and substance problems go up the chain. Bring your BC in early, with facts, not surprises.

Stage 7: Back decisions from above, disagree up the chain

Hill found that new managers expect more authority than they actually get, and instead find themselves in a web of relationships with people above, below, and beside them. That's the company officer's seat: the link between the crew and the chief.

The trap

A new policy comes down that the crew hates. The easy move is to say, "I don't like it either, but the chief says we have to." It feels like loyalty to your crew. It's not. It teaches them to talk about you the same way when you make a call they don't like.

Delivering a decision you didn't make

Own it. Explain the why if you know it. If you don't, find out. Tell them what you'll do with their concerns:

"This is the new policy, and we're going to follow it starting today. Here's the reason I was given. If you see problems with how it works on our shift, bring them to me with specifics, and I'll take them up the chain."

Disagreeing up the chain

Do it in private, with respect, and with facts. Bring the problem, the options, and what you recommend. Put it in writing when it's about staffing, equipment, or training time. Then, whatever the answer is, carry it out like it was yours.

The NFA's Leadership in Supervision course includes a topic it calls active followership. It's a good name for it. Being a good officer includes being a good follower.

Stage 8: Protect your relationships and your boundaries off duty

You don't have to give up your friends. You do have to change some of the rules.

  • Go to the barbecue. But don't talk about other crew members there, and don't make promises about trades, evals, or assignments over a beer.
  • Watch the group chat. Some things you said as a firefighter, you can't say now. Screenshots last forever.
  • Don't let off-duty access turn into on-duty favoritism. If your friend gets the inside scoop at the cookout, everyone else is getting the outside scoop.
  • Talk to your people at home. Tell them what the new job asks of you, and that some friendships are going to feel different for a while.

You also need people you can be straight with who aren't on your crew. That means other officers, and a mentor. The International Association of Fire Chiefs' Officer Development Handbook encourages prospective officers to build themselves up through "seminars, self-study, mentorships, and similar experiences." It also says good mentors "do not tell others what to do but rather present options and challenge mentees to see the 'big picture.'" Find someone like that. Part 8 of the worksheet has room for a short list.

Stage 9: Build credibility over the first 90 days

Hill breaks a new manager's credibility into three pieces. Character is the intention to do the right thing. Competence is knowing how to do it. Influence is being able to actually get it done. The bugles don't give you any of them. You earn them shift by shift.

Small early wins help too. For a new officer, an early win isn't a big change. It's something small the crew has been asking for that you actually get done, like the broken thing that's been out of service for a month or the training that keeps getting skipped. Pick one or two and finish them.

At day 30, 60, and 90, check yourself honestly. Part 7 of the worksheet has the prompts:

  • Character. Have I held the same standard for everybody, including me? Have I owned my mistakes out loud?
  • Competence. Do I know the rig, the radio, the reports, and my crew's skills? Where am I still guessing?
  • Influence. When the crew needed something from up the chain, did it happen? If not, did I tell them why?

Somewhere around day 60 to 90, ask your BC for honest feedback, too.

For formal training, the NFA's Leadership in Supervision series is built for first-line supervisors, people who regularly act up, and people due for promotion within 18 months. NFPA 1020 (which took in the old NFPA 1021 fire officer standard in its 2025 edition) lays out the minimum job performance requirements for Fire Officer I through IV. Neither one will tell you what to say to your best friend in the office at 0700.

Do this next shift

  1. Print the Buddy to Boss Worksheet and fill out the crew map. Be honest about who also tested and who'll test you.
  2. Write your three to five day-one expectations, then mark the one or two you'll hold hardest. Check each of those: can you see it, will you enforce it on a bad day, does it apply to you?
  3. Draft your first line-up in two minutes or less, and say it out loud once before you walk in.
  4. Schedule the two early one-on-ones for your first couple of shifts: your closest friend and anyone who also tested. Everyone else gets a sit-down in your first 30 days.
  5. Start an officer's log tonight. Dates, conversations, praise, corrections.

Your first 90 days set the tone with your crew and your BC for a long time. The free First 90 Days as a Company Officer checklist at companyofficerforge.com walks you through all of them, from before your first shift to day 90.

Where your department's policies, SOPs, or SOGs say something different from anything here, follow them.

Lead the crew you came up with.

Sources